Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Halsey's Restaurant. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
JUMBO LUMP CRAB CAKES
These are the best crab cakes I have ever had. I usually pair them with one of their delicious salads (especially the beet salad) and they never fail to satisfy. Add a pear martini and you have a great meal.
PEAR AND BLUE
This is not your standard pizza!!!! It's an awesome combination of pears, blue cheese and other ingredients atop a delicious wood fired crust!!! I really try to have something different when I dine here but ALWAYS end up ordering this pizza!! ....and, I do not share or need a " take home" box!!!!!💕
PASTA FUNGI
We have been dining at Halsey's for several years and do so because of how accommodating you are to dietary restrictions. Gluten free is not an issue and there is no sacrifice of flavor or consistency in your pasta, rolls or pizza. Cocktails are wonderful and the staff is amazing! Thank you!!!
JUMBO LUMP CRAB CAKES
The best crab cakes I've ever tasted! Great food, great people and awesome service!
JUMBO LUMP CRAB CAKES
I literally dream about these. They are crunchy and the crab is delicious and the sauce it comes with is perfect!!! I love halseys and have probably tried everything on the menu...but these are my favorite!
GRILLED SALMON SALAD
Dressing is light but has a bitter tang to it complimenting the charred salmon. Always a go-to. Always remember to ask if the salmon is wild-caught!
PAN SEARED SCALLOPS
My husband & I love Halsey's. We live in Rochester but a nice ride….usually in the fall. This year my husband requested Halsey's for our anniversary dinner. The warm atmosphere, friendly & knowledgeable waiters top off the experience. Expecting to be delighted soon- Here we come! Susan & Ralph Galletto
MARGHERITA
Halsey's always is our go-to place to step-up our restaurant outing experience in Geneva. If we have family visiting from out of town or a special occasion to celebrate, we love to splurge on dining out at Halsey's. It's conveniently located within walking distance of our home and right next to The Smith Opera House for pre/post entertainment drinks/dinner. Their woodfired pizzas (even gluten-free) and fresh, creative salads are perfect to split with someone you love!
PEAR AND BLUE
Amazing pizza!
THE WEDGE
I dream of this wedge salad... the iceberg lettuce is super crisp, and the bleu cheese dressing... 😍😍😍
THE WEDGE
Everything here was delicious! From the wedge salad to the small plates of crab cakes, cheese board, risotto and scallops, it was all delicious and amazingly cooked to perfection. Our first time having dinner here and we will definitely be back'
GARLIC CRAB
OMG always amazing! We look forward to coming to Halseys every time!! I have a gluten allergy and everyone is always so cautious!! The pizza is phenomenal for gluten free and regular! The garlic crab pizza is the best and the crab farfalle! Also amazing wine list!! Looking forward to my next visit!
PAN SEARED SCALLOPS
Perfect portion small plate, always prepared and plated exquisitely
CARNIVORE
I am gluten sensitive but love pizza. My husband and I only go to Halseys for pizza. Its the best gluten free I've ever had. The waitresses are super nice and the dinner is so relaxing. We're going again soon!
THE HOUSE SPECIALTY
This is a great pizza! The caramelized onions with the blue cheese is fabulous.
THE WEDGE
Almost every time we visit Halsey's we have to have the Wedge. It has spoiled us for wedges anywhere else. So good. The balsamic vinegar gives it the perfect finish!
PAN SEARED SCALLOPS
Cooked to perfection!!
CARNIVORE
The Carnivoe Pizza was delicious and just the right amount to feel comfortably full but not overfull. Wonderful crispy crust with just the right amount of sauce. Never had better.
MARGHERITA
Love Love the Margherita Pizza. Gluten allergy and Halseys has the most delicious gluten free options! Staff is very well trained and knowledgeable on menu items that are gluten free and very friendly ( which is so hard to find in restaruants) and glad to help with any questions. Atmosphere is always awesome cannot recommend enough you will not be disappointed.
PASTA FUNGI
The sauce was incredibly made, the pasta was soft and melted in my mouth. 5/5
8 OZ. FILET MIGNON
Filet Mignon was cooked to perfection. Absolutely melted in my mouth. My only issue now is trying out the rest of the menu when I know this dish is so good!!
8 OZ Black Angus Beef Burger
Great burger. You have try one.
MEATBALL
The meatballs are delightful, highly recommend. Best Bartender in town S/o MJ.
WOOD FIRED VEGETABLE LASAGNA
Absolutely the best. The balsamic glaze topped it off perfectly. Loved the house salad. Everything was fresh and excellent quality. Enjoyed the pumpkin ale.
THE HOUSE SPECIALTY
Delish toppings and crust!! Will have it again and again!
MEATBALL
The meatballs were amazing!!! Definitely recommend to get as an appetizer and I would order them again.
8 OZ. FILET MIGNON
I rarely order beef, but as a birthday treat, it screamed out to me from the menu that evening back in April. I was not disappointed! In fact, this melt-in-my mouth filet was one of the most delicious dinners I have ever had in a restaurant. It was grilled to perfect and SO tender! I also recall the delicious potato side, a cheesy layered galette, I believe, and grilled to perfection fresh spring asparagus. Halseys has been and remains a favorite go-to restaurant for a special occasion, or no occasion at all! We're never disappointed by the food, drink, or service! (Mary Ann was our server that night😊👍.) Please open a Canandaigua location!
WOOD FIRED VEGETABLE LASAGNA
By far my favorite dish at Halsey's. Before I had to go GF - this was my go-to dish. Now just waiting for thus to move to gluten free!
GRILLED FILET OF SALMON
Loved this!!!! Perfect gluten free meal! Quinoa great too!
VEGGIE
The Veggie Pizza was amazing! The different cheese blends were tantalizing and refreshing. The crust was a perfect soft to crisper ratio. Trust me I'm from NYC and I know my pizza, Hasley's Restaurant probably has the best pizza on this side of New York!
8 OZ Black Angus Beef Burger
The beef was cooked perfectly to my request (rare), and the truffles were great. Would totally recommend to a friend. Hoping to return in a few weeks to try out another item on the menu!
THE WEDGE
OMG!! I had never had a wedge until getting it here, man have I been missing out!! Have since tried them at other places, but none compare to Hasley's!!
GRILLED SALMON SALAD
As always, we had a great dinner. We started with an appetizer of fried calamari, which was delicious. Our party of 4 also enjoyed the duck breast special, which was perfectly cooked, the salmon dinner, the salmon salad , the wedge salad and the house specialty pizza, which was huge and yummy. Decent wine list. Our server, Lily, was pleasant and attentive. We always enjoy our evenings at Halsey's and would highly recommend.
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
June 2020:
Coming Soon
May 2020:
Carlson, Papi Grande's Mexican
Amherst, NY
April 2020:
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery
Thousand Oaks, CA
March 2020:
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD
February 2020:
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Riverside, CA
January 2020:
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Florence, SC
December 2019:
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Jacksonville, FL
November 2019:
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Seattle, WA
October 2019:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Portland, OR
September 2019:
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA
August 2019:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Columbus, GA
July 2019:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Buffalo, NY
June 2019:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA
May 2019:
Karen, This Little Pig
Amherst, NY
April 2019:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria
Atlanta, GA